Wednesday, December 31, 2014

Strange Beauty: Secrets

Secrets.  I don’t exactly know if by secrets I mean the recipe for Grandma’s Hunter’s Goulash, or if I mean who dunnit?... What is meant by secret? “Glorious delight that makes one smile and fuels energy which cannot be stolen by any creature…” That is my own embellished definition of secret.  I couldn’t even give this article the title “Strange and Beautiful Secrets” because I’m not entirely sure that secrets are beautiful.
Secrets have been wounds which morph into weapons.  Secrets have been hospitals for the soul, as well as catalysts for change.  Secrets have solidified the sense of individuality for some, and have created gulfs between others.  There are secrets for privacy, and there are secrets for shame.  I am not sure that secrets have ever brought two together, unless the two share a deep secret from the rest of the world, thus allowing the secret to wrap its arms around them and pull them close.  Sometimes it is a blackmailing hug imposed on those who share a secret; sometimes it is a delicious embrace.
Do you know what it is to have a wound from a secret?  One small part of me thinks that maybe I should save this as my final point, the one thing that will draw us together – all of us bandaging our multitude of wounds from secrets.  Another part of me wants to talk only about this.  I want to expose my wounds from secrets and drink wine and cry.  Did you know…? And, One time this happened to me… What secret-induced wound can I tell you about that will not injure someone I have forgiven since the wound occurred, or which will not divulge too much of my own life? This is a dilemma.  I’m writing a blog, not a journal.  I aim to forgive. Does forgiving mean forgetting, as well?  I know the answer already.  I toy with not answering.  Once upon a time I wrote a long bit of poetry which was born from learning of an incident that hurt me so deeply I could not let it go.  The knowledge was devastating, but the fact that it had been hidden from me was even more painful. I awoke almost nightly for months, rolling over in my sleep and stifling sobs before restlessly falling back to sleep.  I often got up and paced the floor, going to the mirror in my living room and looking at the dark shadow of myself to see if there was anything worth glimpsing.  I had allowed newfound knowledge to rip my self-confidence from me, and I was frightened that I would never get my groove back.  I questioned everything I previously thought to be real, and tortured myself with a new reality based on the secret. Finally, after many months of wallowing, I wrote a poem.  It was painful to write, but not writing it had robbed me of my creativity.  I would go do music therapy daily, writing songs with patients, then come home at night and squeeze tears from the corners of my eyes while avoiding my own need to express.  I would scroll FaceBook on my phone until it was an appropriate time to go to bed.  This was a dangerous pit in which to have fallen.  I am a person who needs to write.  I need to sing.  I need to draw and sew and create new recipes.  I have a voracious appetite for art, and it oozes from me in various forms.  This is not an indulgence.  This is how I am able to function and fit into society’s box for a few hours a week.  Art is how I am upright and breathing. Art is how I love people.  Art is not a thing I do; it is essential to the fiber of my being.  If you are wired as I am, you understand.  So, to have this stunted in my personal life, to find myself unable to produce it while nursing a pain from someone else’s secret, was to suffer an injury of substance.  I finally faced the ugly words and accusations that were endlessly swirling in my head.  I finally sat down and spilled the blood of music that no one will ever hear.  I penned the words “I have never been the same.”  I continued for six pages of ink on paper, feverishly writing an epic tale of how affected I was.  Finally, I wrote,
“I have never been the same
But I am trying to be a strong, new me.
You do deserve it.
I forgive.  But, you deserve for me to forget, too.”

            The truth is, if I released all the secrets which wounded, the flood-gates would open and I would drown in the waters.  It’s not necessary to do that in order for you to understand.  It’s not even healthy for me to do that in order to remember.  I don’t know that I could let them all go, the secrets others in my life have had, in one fell swoop, so maybe it’s best to not go there.  I write a lot about forgiveness, and I will continue to write about it.  When teaching voice, I always say that breath is the most important aspect of singing.  Breath is the energy, it is what gives life to our sound.  It is also that which renews our phrases if we get off-track.  Everything can be “fixed” with a new breath.  I think, for today’s writing, I want to say forgiveness is the breath of our relationships. 
            It seems that when secrets have been wounds, many of us inadvertently find ourselves wielding a sword to avenge our wounds.   How easy it is for the hurt to become the hurter.  And so it is that if secrets have been painful, some of us have found ourselves creating secrets for the simple purpose of revenge.  We have perhaps created secrets just to withhold them.  He/she doesn’t tell about that, so I will create a new email account for myself that he/she never gets to know about, and that he/she will NEVER know the password (insert high-pitched cackle).  Or, She makes plans with everyone but me, so I will cancel our coffee-date and call so-and-so (someone we both used to know, and who will become my new closer friend) and make plans with her.  That’ll show her… Nothing good really comes of the vengeful secrets.  I want to say we don’t do this anymore once we grow up, but we do.
            There have been times when I have made decisions that were just for me.  I didn’t share them for a while with anyone.  They were mine and mine alone, and I reveled in my secrets each time I needed to escape the sadness of my chapter.  I don’t want to say the sadness of my life, because I believe my life has been full of much happiness.  However, many of the chapters have held extreme sadness.  Sometimes secrets are hospitals for the soul like this.
            A secret crush; a secret hiding place; a walking route that one takes all alone, full of alone-thoughts to release stress and tension – these are some of the secrets I’ve created to bandage up my battered spirit and simply breathe.  I had a secret crush when I was in middle school, and the only person who knew was my very bestest friend.  My crush’s initials were R.E., and so we created a diversion and called my love “S.F.”  Of course, we came up with the code name by taking the letters in the alphabet which directly followed his real initials.  When anyone asked, though, we both said that “S.F” stood for “SuperFox.”  It was not only fun to have a secret crush (although I was so over-the-moon crazy about him that I cannot imagine he didn’t know how he held me captivated), but it became even more fun to stump the entire student body.  Everyone wanted to know who this “S.F.” was.  I maintained my secrecy until my brother found my diary, unlocked it, and called “S.F.” to reveal.  Yep.  That’s when my mother sat me down, tear-streaked stains on my cheeks, and gently informed me that it was a hard lesson to learn, but I shouldn’t put anything in writing that would devastate me if it were to be read by someone else. I’m still working on that, Mom.
            The hospital for my soul as a young and melancholy teenager was the Hessel Bay on Lake Huron.  I lived about a quarter mile walk from the docks, and would make that walk daily.  My first stop was the post office to mail multitudes of letters, and then I would wander over to the water where I’d sit on a beautiful series of large rocks (they used to be accessible before the docks were renovated and gazebos were built).  On the rocks, I wrote many letters, poems, plays and songs.  I drew pictures of romantic figures dressed in Victorian attire, or sketched wildlife.  I dreamed of being tall.  I dreamed of being a mother (at that age, I dreamed I had lots of beautiful small children, and yet my figure was petite and slim.  My husband, whoever he may be, was always tragically killed overseas, or had run off with some disreputable sort.  I was always forced to be strong and independent in my reveries).  I dreamed of being on the Johnny Carson Show, being interviewed as a famous playwright. 
Writing was always my favorite secret.  I wrote my first novel when I was nine.  It had ten chapters, ten pages each.  Anything was possible when I wrote, and the wounds were created and salve was applied to the wounds, all controlled by my words alone.  No one could say it was right or wrong, because most of my work was a secret.
As I got older, the secret places were less beautiful than my paradise of the Hessel Bay.  The rest of the world is not really as beautiful as Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, so locating untouched rocks and shorelines for contemplating dreams and magical words became nearly impossible.  As a young mother, I found myself plopping my babies in a stroller and walking through towns on sidewalks.  The babies would sleep (blessed rhythmic jostling) and I would dream again.  I would daydream some of the same things – minus being a widow.  (Honestly, I am a little alarmed that I told you all that I imagined as a twelve and thirteen-year-old that I birthed a passel of children and acquired a dead husband.  I promise I no longer fancied the dead-husband part once I got older…) Sometimes the healing that secrets and dreams provide gives us strength to make necessary decisions for our health.  I think that’s where having a secret can be a catalyst for change. It is just tricky, and I suppose one needs to be aware that our minds are wild and monstrous at times, capable of creating problems where none existed.  Secrets, emerging from the monsters, can be terrible.  Secrets healing the pain are not the same as secrets spawned from monsters.
            I do believe unveiling secrets, at least for women, is a sign of trust.  I have found that I slowly release control of my secret-self when I feel that the other person is going to treat me and my quirks with respect.  When he or she will cherish the secret me, then he or she gets to have the secret me.  However, from experience of being the trusting and free-spirited girl of my youth who got crushed a time or two, I have learned that such secrets shouldn’t be revealed all at once.  If I slowly give you a key which opens another door to the next room inside my soul, then you are special.  You are trusted.  You are one layer closer to being my dearest one.  It’s a terrifying thing to give a V.I.P. pass to your heart and soul.  Secret Laura is safe with me. My husband said that to me long before he became my husband.  Actually, he said that long before I was necessarily safe with him, before he knew that I didn’t freely share myself and that this information was exclusive.  He had access to me like no other, and it was not something that was explainable.  It was reckless of me, honestly. I suppose love is reckless, though.  He had no idea how important this phrase (Secret Laura is safe with me) was going to be.  I think it might not be as complex for guys.  I’m not sure.  I do know, though, that men have their secrets, too.  They keep their accounts and passwords.  They keep their compartmentalized memories of events and experiences with people who were not you – and don’t divulge.  They keep those details.  Women want to know “who, what, when, where.”  We want to also tell “who, what, when, where” from our own lives, to exorcise demons, I suppose.  But, men want to keep us separate from the “who, what, when, and where” of their past.  They like to maintain their routines that were created before we were part of them, and they struggle to surrender this.  The surrender is a ceremonial crucifixion of the secret box inside of them where their memories and fantasies – and perhaps bits of their identities – are held.  I think of a lyric from a musical by Jason Robert Brown.  He briefly addressed this very thing in his musical The Last Five Years.  The male character is contemplating his wife’s discovery of this secret place inside his heart. 
All that I ask for
Is one little corner
One private room
At the back of my heart
Tell her I found one
She sends out battalions
To claim it and blow it apart

Every time I hear Norman Leo Butz sing this, I cry.  I don’t want to be the wife in this song.  I want to allow my husband to have a corner in his heart where he remembers other girls he loved, without me horning in on that.  I want to be secure enough that he can remember who he gave a song to, or what trip he took, or where he went camping or hiking, or any of the things that maybe he hasn’t done with me… without feeling pain stab at me, and a false sense of not being enough.  He is allowed to have his secrets still.  I know I have some.  They are not for the same reason.  My secrets are probably rooted mostly in shame.  I hold no memory so dear that I cannot offer it to him with a promise that my memories with him trump the ones I have with anyone else. But I do hold secrets for fear of hurting others. God knows I have done some awful things, and some of them have not been that long ago if you take a perspective that I am no longer young.  It’s funny how different a woman’s language of secrets is from a man’s.  I offer to him what I need – everything.  He offers to me what he needs – privacy, independence, individuality.  Can I be mature enough to not ask for everything – not ask for every corner of his heart?  Can I wait patiently for him to make his own decision about whether he wants to make new secrets with me in old favorite places of his memories?  Can I just be safe in knowing that I am the most precious person to him, and that his compartments are not indications that this is not so?  His compartments might exist for him to cling to a place where he is completely and utterly in control. And he needs that, for reasons I do not completely understand.
Or do I?
I understand.  I think I understand very well, but my own experience with keeping a locked compartment in my heart resulted in a division, and I want to be careful to avoid this with anyone I love.  I remember many years ago when I was teaching voice lessons at the university where I was pursuing a degree in vocal performance. I was talking with my own vocal instructor about one of my students, and my teacher said something profound to me.  She said, “Laura, that is your specific vocal challenge.”  We were talking about vocal tension.  “Be careful not to project your issues onto your student.  Does she have tension?  Or is it something else?”  I had to really think about this.  In the end, I determined that my student did not have vocal tension.  She had a completely different issue, and if I had approached her lessons trying to fix tension (my own issue) which she did not have, I was going to miss the opportunity to help her.  How is this related to secret boxes in hearts, you ask?  Well, just because my secret box led me to close up and push everyone I love away from me – that being my own issue – does not mean that my husband, or anyone else’s husband, is going to do the same.  Fifteen years ago, I had a secret box and I allowed it to form a gulf between me and those closest to me.  I am pre-disposed to thinking that everyone in the whole world who has a secret box in their heart is going to do the same thing.  It just isn’t so.  Each of us is responsible for our own boxes, and while secrets can create gulfs between friends and lovers, they don’t always.  It is not my right to bring in battalions and blow apart anyone’s box of secrets.  It is each person’s specific right to release their secrets as they are ready and able.
Being the daughter of a pastor, I knew many other pastors, and was privy to secrets, I suppose, of some.  This being the case, I knew a couple, a minister and his wife, who were both married before they married each other.  When the man went into the ministry, he believed that the grace of God covered anything that happened (ever in his life) but, in particular, that which had occurred before he became a Christian. It was, and never will be, any other human’s business whether he or his wife had been married to anyone else.  Yet, many people extract one of Paul’s writings in the New Testament and dissect it to allow for righteous judging of others on this issue.  This man would shake his head and smile as he said, “If only I’d been a convicted felon – a killer or a rapist who came to know Christ while in prison.  Then, my life transformation would be something that others would accept without question.  But, no.  I am a divorced man.  God cannot use me, according to some certain denominations.”  The secret of this man was not meant to do anything but protect privacy. However, there is a fine line between privacy and shame.  I believe in privacy.  And, about matters of the soul, I believe in utmost privacy.  Humans are not allowed to judge and decide on these matters.
            Privacy and shame can manifest themselves in the same way, though.  One of my secrets is that whenever I gain ten pounds (I gain and lose the same ten or fifteen pounds), I don’t want my husband to see my extra fat on my tummy, and I try to look as though I have not gained the ten pounds.  I tuck (and tuck and tuck) my tummy the best I can, and stand up straight, and wear clothing that doesn’t cinch my waist, but which falls gently over the waistline.  I try to not get caught in unbecoming positions while changing in my own room.  I am ridiculously self-conscious about when I bend over and when I’m lying on my side.  It is truly exhausting.  The reality is, I’m not hiding anything from him; and, he likely isn’t really noticing the little extra fold.  I don’t think he’s scrutinizing my every pound the way I do to myself.  I know I certainly am not doing that to him.  I am hungry for his eyes, and look across the room to find them.  He is doing the same to me.  Our eyes lock, and the love wells up like tears, spilling out.  There is no room for this nasty criticism I am trying to avoid in the first place. His fingers gently pushing a strand of hair from my eyes, or his strong arms around me, holding me close and making me feel warm – these are the daily interactions that we share.  We do not stop and assess the hunk of flesh before our eyes, deciding if it is one-sixteenth of a pound fatter than it was the day before, thus not earning our affection.  It is a little ridiculous, if I stop to think about it.  I may think I have a shameful secret (except that I just exposed it in this writing), but it was probably never a secret in the first place.  What it actually is… is no big deal.  It’s no big deal, and it is not a factor, as I mistakenly assume it is.
            Blackmailing secrets are not anything with which I necessarily have personal experience.  I always think about the book I read as a preteen (and I assume on which the movie by the same name was based):  I Know What You Did Last Summer… I suppose I have never been savvy or cruel enough to use this on someone else, and I am thankful that it hasn’t really been used on me.  Although, I have a wicked imagination, and can come up with instances where it might have been used… I rather like to end my discussion of secrets with the idea of them instigating delicious embrace, though, instead of blackmail.
            It’s the new year, shortly here.  I have had a year (2014) full of lessons, exhaustion, intrigue, colorful experiences, pain, joy, passion, and love.  I have come face to face with my fears of self-image, my anxieties and obsessions, my need to let go of control, and my human tendency to feel too deeply.  I sometimes sense I have been split wide open, all secrets exposed, all flaws on display awaiting correction.  I have felt this year as though ugly parts of me, parts I thought had healed long ago, were exposed in that same series of spirit-traumas which cracked open my secrets.  I found out that I am not as gracious or forgiving as I like to say I am.  I found out that I am mean, sometimes, and that I inadvertently judge other people still.  I found out that I haven’t got as great a handle on self-love as I thought.  I found out through intimacy – mind, body, spirit – with my husband, that sometimes I am still looking at myself through garish eyes of my mean-girl self.  I found out that I crave a deeper relationship with God, and that this craving propels me into embracing my husband, children, siblings and parents more. It also asks me to love myself better, to choose to seek a better physical me out of love rather than out of self-hate.
            The secrets I wish to discuss, then, as a final point are the ones that cause me to embrace those I love more closely. Sometimes we call these private jokes.  Sometimes we call these secrets “pet names.”  Sometimes maybe they are comfort-food recipes, or maybe even wordless glances between two.  I don’t know if we always refer to them as secrets.  They are actually little bits of precious intimacy.  No one can draw me a picture and tell a story quite like my youngest.  No one can sit with me and hold a saturated moment of understanding like my sisters.  No one can say, “Aw, babes, that’s all I really want for you,” like my dad, in a lucid moment when talking about love.  No one can understand my adoration for shoes like my mother, unless, of course, it is my oldest daughter.  No one can understand my pain of being away from my children for weeks at a time like my brother.  No one understands my drive to do well like my second-born.  No one really understands the sweet fever that music is for me quite like my son.  No one can kiss my forehead as sweetly as my husband, making me feel safe and alive all at the same time.   These are, I suppose, our secrets.  They are secrets because they are our moments, shared by only us.  They are not the secrets which create gulfs; not the kind that need to be gently exposed in timely fashions.  There is no heart-room where they must be hoarded.  They are private, but not so much that I cannot tell you they exist.  These are our secrets which cause us to embrace each other. 
I have my secrets like this, and I pray you have yours. Have a blessed New Year…

  

No comments:

Post a Comment