“I
want to sing,” she stated to me simply.
“I
want to sing,” she said again with tears in her eyes.
“I
want to sing. And I don’t understand why
I cannot sing,” she continued, with anguish in her voice.
“I
should be able to sing, but…” she stated finally, collapsing into the chair
with defeat.
I
looked at the mother of four in front of me, a woman probably in her
mid-forties. She was meticulously
dressed, revealing a lovely figure. Her
hair and make-up were carefully attended to, and her soft fragrance filled the
air – something I could not quite place, but it spoke of quality. Everything about her spoke of quality. I knew her to be a conscientious and
hardworking woman and she was someone I already admired. Yet, here she was in my studio, hoping that I
could help her find her voice.
“Let
me see what I can do. I cannot promise
you a singing voice. But I can promise
you that I will do everything in my power to investigate what’s happening and
to help see if we can get to the bottom of what’s not working, OK?” It was the best I could do. I wished I could offer a magic pill. However, she breathed a sigh of relief, and
agreed.
“That
sounds good,” she replied.
We
worked closely for many months, easing her into songs and held tones. Denise--
let’s call her-- had the makings of a beautiful voice: a melodious speaking
voice, rich in timbre, and good breath control in her speech. In fact, Denise told me that she occasionally
recorded commercials for radio stations, and enjoyed giving speeches.
Mechanically her voice seemed to be in healthy working order. However, when she attempted singing, it was
almost as if she was strangling her own voice to keep it from coming out. The sound was alarmingly far back in her throat,
and holding tones appeared to be physically stressful on the muscles
surrounding the vocal folds.
As
a gung-ho vocal technician, I attempted a couple of exercises with her, and we
met with tentative success. The
exercises included singing with a cartoon voice, pretending to be a (gorgeous, mesmerizing) opera singer, or
meowing like a kitty/whimpering like a puppy (and other exercises that tossed
her voice forward with natural breath support, but in a playful way). These exercises revealed an extraordinary hidden
instrument. The goal for us was now to
discover what was obstructing the singing voice, inhibiting the freedom of the
held tone. We made up a series of
descriptions for where the voice was when it was not forward. We picked Negaunee, Michigan as the “far-away”
place. I’d say, “Ope! Your voice just
went to Negaunee,” and then we’d laugh and try again.
Through
careful work, we explored her voice. We
learned lots of small things, for sure.
We learned that Denise had one of the highest voices with which I’d ever
worked, and that she had great control in her upper registers. She had a pretty vibrato, when we were able
to get her to release the tone enough to let the vibrato happen. We also learned one really big thing about
singing, which is at the heart of the entire story of Denise struggling to sing: We cannot separate our spiritual selves from
our physical selves.
Let
me try to explain. One lesson, the day
of epiphany, Denise came in as usual.
She was dressed in a black flower-printed dress, and black low-heeled
pumps. Her hair was perfectly coiffed, and she had the appropriately classy
combination of accessories and fragrance.
She smiled sweetly, and gregariously launched into a greeting.
“How
did the vocalizing go this week?” I
asked her as we approached the piano.
“It
was difficult to practice this week. I
just have such a hard time if I think anyone is going to hear me.” She was gently placing her coat on a chair
next to the piano.
“That’s
how a lot of people feel. You’re not
alone,” I reassured her. This was
true. I even sometimes felt awkward
practicing if anyone was listening, and I’d been singing my entire life.
“I
know my husband loves me and supports me in this. That isn’t something I’m used to. Still. I mean, I’m learning. But it’s hard to change
your thinking.” Over the course of the
past few weeks I had learned a little about Denise’s life. She’d been married for many years to a man
with whom she had four children. That marriage
ended, about five years before I met Denise, and now Denise was remarried to
Nathan.
“Nathan
loves it when you sing.” I’d met her
husband a couple of times, and he was a lovely man who adored Denise. They had developed a beautiful relationship
where they respected each other and encouraged growth. I could sense, even before she told me, that Denise
had been in an oppressive marriage the first time around, feeling very much
like someone who wasn’t allowed to voice her opinions. She had been belittled and her self-esteem
had been chipped away little by little over twenty years. I believe when Nathan picked her up, she was
a mere skeleton of the luscious woman he was about to unfold. Nathan, himself, was a singer/songwriter who
played guitar and performed sometimes locally.
Naturally, he encouraged Denise to find her singing voice.
“I
wish I could sing with him. He would
love that, too. I think I can, and then
as soon as I get around anyone, the sound goes back to that other place, and I
can’t bring myself to do it. I just don’t
know what’s happening.” She was
exasperated. Her desire to be a singer
battled with her obstruction. In that
moment, it occurred to me that her fear (the true obstruction) was stronger
than anything I could really give her.
It was not a fear of her first husband’s scorn, or a fear of not
pleasing her lovely husband now. It was
not a fear of failure. It was not a
pressure to sing well because all of her children were beautiful singers.
It
was a fear of being herself.
Fear
is a funny thing. I have contemplated it
for so long that the philosopher living inside of me has lost track of the
beginning and end. The topic has looped
itself into a circular never-ending-or-beginning rung on the ladder of
most-thought-of-thoughts. I would tell
everyone, especially all my voice students, about fear in this way: “Fear,” I would say, “is bigger than
anything. Gee, I wish I could tell you
that you can conquer fear with another strong emotion. Love is bigger, I wish I could say. Or, certainly shouldn’t courage be bigger
than fear?” I would then look at you and shake my head, “Fear is bigger than
courage.”
I
know. That sounds really fatalistic,
doesn’t it? I really believe that the
rest of what I have to say on the topic will bring a little relief,
though. I believe it will help take the
sting out of the fatalism. Fear is
stronger than all of the other emotions.
Let’s
look at musicians and fear. The singer is
especially hard hit, because her instrument is physiologically part of the
human body. I mean, if someone wants to
criticize the sound of a piano sonata, while it most likely is due to
user-error, there is a bit of blame which the user can extend to the
instrument. “Yes, I could not play those
octaves because the enamel is missing from the keys down there.” The crowd nods in sympathy. Yes,
the enamel. Or, “I know it looks
like I never learned my scales because I botched them in my continuous attempt
at them throughout this entire, scale-laced, Mozart piano concerto, but the
action of this piano is really inferior…” The crowd agrees and extends
grace. Yes, that inferior action.
But,
if the human voice does not come out right, there is nowhere to place that
blame other than fully on the body from which the human voice emerges. There is no one to blame but the one person
who is making sound; and, blame is such an important aspect of how we
cope. We must blame something, and with
the voice, we blame ourselves. If the
human voice goes to “Negaunee,” we clearly sent it there. If we sound odd or off-key, we are humiliated
to the point of not wanting to be heard by any other living creature, not
wanting the pain of rejection or harassment because we have a discernable flaw. Our voice is in our body, and for the
aspiring singer, this means we are often defined by the success of our body’s
attempts to make beautiful sound. If I
am saying that fear is in control, then I am saying that our self-image (in
this particular case) is determined by our failed attempts to make this
sought-after beautiful sound simply by the default that our worth is defined by
our body which is controlled by fear.
Ooooo. Big sentence, but read it
again. I should make it into an
algebraic phrase with x’s and y’s and parentheses. It’s complex and yet true. Something inside of us says, “Our worth is
defined by our body.” If it is not
beautiful, if it is not strong, if it is not whole, if it is not functioning at
star-quality on all levels, we are suddenly thrown into a dark-tunnel of
negative self- talk. No one can prevent herself from thinking thoughts. Not even you
can stop you. I can’t stop me. Too often we are not
cultivating proper self-talk, not telling ourselves, “Make sure your words to
yourself are good ones.”
I
will continue with Denise’s story in a moment.
I first want to take you somewhere else with me. I want to take you to my high school, where I
was a teenage track runner. While I was
willing to put myself out there, I was not a great runner, by any stretch of
the imagination. I was not a sprinter,
and my pace wasn’t really fast enough to be an 800-meter runner. I had a lot of stamina, so I went for the
two-mile run. I trained with all my
heart and did what I could to grow stronger and faster. In track meets, I often made up the caboose of
the two-milers, just a quarter-lap behind the second-to-last runner. As I got better, I pushed myself, and
sometimes I didn’t come in last. I beat
my own time every week in track meets.
Aw. Sweet story of courage, right? Wrong.
I should tell you about my fear. I
was so sick all day, every day we had a track meet. I knew I needed calories, but was so nauseous
(starting the night before the meet) that I couldn’t eat or keep anything down. I would eat one peanut M & M every hour
during the day of the meet to pretend I was giving myself energy. I wanted to quit track right before every
meet. I was terrified of being
seen. I didn’t like being last, as I was
accustomed to being good at everything else I did. It didn’t really feel good to almost always
come in last (although, in retrospect, someone has to, right?). Every week, my fear had me so terrified of
what I’d ask myself to publically do that I was nauseous and starving. Every week, I fought hyperventilating,
recognizing that my body was trying to respond to this fear. I did use courage to make my legs walk to the
track and get in place to start the race.
Yes, courage did that. But
courage didn’t run eight laps for me. Do
you know what ran eight laps for me while also whittling down race time (by many
seconds) every single track meet in the
season?
Technique.
When
you train yourself, you give yourself the only thing that you can use to
eradicate fear, and that is technique. This
is about the most comforting thing I can say.
I love knowing that I can remove emotion from being responsible for
fighting fear. Fighting fear with love and
courage had not worked out for me in other settings, and it always left me
feeling like it was a crapshoot. Which emotion is in charge today? Eeny-meeny-miney-moe…
Where
does fear come from? That seems like a good place to start. My fear of running came from my fear of
body-image, in part. I was afraid of
people seeing me in a vulnerable way. I
had never liked my own figure (which I now find so sad and funny. I like myself, and find myself so much more
beautiful, as a grown-up mother than I ever did as a young and slender teen. I could not see that I was attractive then). Self-confidence is so dependent when we are
young, though. It’s so dependent on what
others think.
My
fear also probably came because I didn’t believe I could do it. I was not the athlete. I was the artist, musician, thespian, and
scholar. I was not physically strong or
swift or sculpted. I might be setting
myself up for failure. And there is nothing in this world that is
worse than failure for the young over-achiever…
Fear
comes from pre-conceived notions and societal pressures and insecurities and oppression. Let’s take this story back to Denise. Denise shared with me that she’d spent most
of her life “not speaking my mind.”
“My therapist asked me what I do when
I’m angry. It occurred to me that I don’t
do anything. I have spent so many years
never being angry. I often wondered where all the anger must have gone, because
it’s not like I didn’t have it. I had to
have put that somewhere.” Denise was
opening up to me about her life before Nathan.
“I felt like no one ever heard me,
anyway. So, what was the point of
expressing my dissatisfaction?” She
laughed nervously, belying the pain of one who had a voice buried beneath many
layers.
“Denise, have you ever considered
that your voice was the one thing small enough that you could be in control of
it?” I said the words before I understood
my meaning. We both stopped and thought. I continued.
“Your voice has little, tiny muscles.
If you sent your anger there, let those muscles handle your pain, then
you didn’t have to acknowledge the pain anywhere else.”
Denise looked at me, and
realization dawned in her eyes. She
nodded slowly, and tears began to fall. “I
think you may be right.”
“Denise, there appears to be no physiological
reason why you cannot sing,” I told her.
She had already been to specialists who found nothing wrong with the
mechanics of her voice. I had worked
with her on making sounds, and she was able to reproduce healthy sound (even if
sporadically). There was no apparent scientific
reason to explain the far-back-placement (or, as we called it, “going to
Negaunee”). It became evident to me, the
more Denise shared, that fear was the
culprit, revealing an intricate self-preservation tool. This tool was developed for processing
extreme emotions about an unhappy, unraveling marriage which had been endured
for many years before anyone had the strength to put an end to it.
It’s ingenious, really, to place
stress and tension on a little set of muscles where no one should be able to
witness destruction. No one will find this anger and aggression
as long as it’s in my singing voice. I don’t
need to use that…
Ah, no. You don’t need to use it until one day you
do. Denise didn’t even know she’d
sabotaged the process of learning to sing with her repressed urges to scream
and fight back, until this day that we fell upon this epiphany. Her journey to healing was asking, requiring,
her to use a singing voice. Her emotional-self thought that she was done with
the past.
I said to Denise, “We are not given
dreams if we are not also intended to pursue them.” I said it simply and with
conviction. It is one of those things I
can still say today, with just as much conviction.
“Denise, you are meant to
sing. Do not give up,” I continued. She and I both wept as we continued
talking. She shared how she had previously
been made to feel insignificant and “crazy.”
She couldn’t fight back against the narcissism of her first spouse, which
appeared to manifest itself as a personality disorder. She found it easier to smile and agree, to be
quiet; to not sing, if you will.
Earlier I stated that the spiritual
self and the physical self are not two separate selves. When one is sick, the other is affected. It was clear that Denise’s physical singing voice
was tormented because of being conditioned to suppress her creativity. To acknowledge her creative self would
involve a jailbreak for some of those intense emotions she’d been squelching. Her singing voice, we determined, was being
held hostage to her former self. Nathan
was great for her, and poured belief and love into her daily. The real freedom would come when Denise came
to a point where she could open that box of emotions, which, I’m guessing was
located inside her voice box. The
freedom and healing would come about when the fear was directly addressed.
I cannot imagine a more profound
word-picture than to tell you that a woman I knew and loved had suppressed her
voice through years of oppression. This is true on the humblest level; and,
looking at how fear affects the masses of people through silencing their passions
and dreams, it is true on a larger level.
It is true because people struggle
to find time to breathe and sing and bake.
People are afraid to show others their drawings or their paintings. Folks are cutting the collective arts
programs from schools, many saying those programs are unnecessary. It baffles me. Unnecessary?
I beg to differ. If Denise had
not had to desire to start singing at forty-something, maybe she would not have
really started to intimately understand her mind’s own dark alley. When she came face to face with her fears and
realized how complex they were, she began finding a path that would allow her
to blossom artistically. She began to
sing, among many other things.
The development of art in our
persons becomes the process through which we can access the windows inside our
souls. Let me say that again. The
development of art in our persons becomes the process through which we can
access the windows inside our souls. Without
art, how can we find our true selves – our true selves at their most
vulnerable, at their most beautiful, and at their most terrified? Anything other than that, I’m afraid, just
won’t do. The level of passion in any
form of art which causes an individual to feel something – there is a message
in that feeling. Discomfort asks us to
grow, to expand and meet the depth of the challenge. This is what happened to Denise with her
quest and journey to find her singing voice.
I want
to say to everyone, “If you want to sing, then sing. Let nothing stop you. If you want to be
something brand new today, something you have never let yourself be before this
moment in time, don’t let yesterday tell you that you cannot.”
What I
would interpret that to mean for myself is that if I want to draw, I should
draw. If I want to paint, paint. If I want to dance, dance. If I want to run, run. I think I understand fear enough to know that
it really is just an emotion. A big,
giant, dominant emotion. But, just an emotion.
Seriously. And, the only
technique (this training that we talked about earlier) that we need in life to
beat fear is that of physical action. We can, scared as we may be, just do it. Generally speaking, no bombs will simultaneously
explode upon our rebel cries as we charge against fear. However, we may find ourselves singing a
strange and beautiful song of victory…