Strange
beauty can come from conversations – places we least expect to find
beauty. I had such a time as this
yesterday when visiting with my dad. He
is nearing the end of his life, it would seem, through a battle with dementia
of the Alzheimer’s variety. He has been
slipping from us for a while, both physically and mentally. It seems as though the race of decline
between his physical and mental persons has been evening out lately, and he is
as frail in his walking as he is in his remembering. Sometimes, he is present and can talk about
things in ways that you almost cannot see the most accurate decline. Other times, he is repetitive and disruptive,
asking the same urgent question fifty or sixty times within a one-hour
span. I experienced this in the early
part of my day with him yesterday. My
mom, who is solely caring for my dad at home, had to make her own trip to see
the doctor, since she’d been feeling sick for a few days. She was trying to get herself ready to leave,
and also trying to visit with me and share conversation. It occurred to me that my dad’s questions and
interruptions became more prolific as his anxiety about her leaving heightened. I am not sure if it was related, but he
definitely seemed to feed off of the energy increase in the room.
Soon, with much effort, my mom left,
and I was busy in the dining room (adjacent to the living room where Dad was
cuddled up in his chair). I was working
on some projects I had brought along, and I suddenly realized it had been very
quiet for about ten minutes. Concerned
that Dad might need something, I came to his side and checked on him.
“Are you doing OK, Dad? Do you want me to get you a little more to
eat or drink?”
“Oh.
So you’re babysitting me, huh?”
He said it with a twinkle in his eye, a bit of sadness behind the
twinkle. I did my best to lighten his
statement without denying it.
“I’m here to visit, Dad. Are you feeling like resting, or do you need
anything?”
“Where’s Mom?” Dad asked. This question had been asked a couple of
times already, and would be asked a few more times throughout the day.
“Oh, she’s just at the
doctor’s. She’ll be back pretty
soon.” I then repeated the question
about whether he needed anything.
“I just need you to come in here and
visit with me for a while,” he answered softly.
He leaned his head back against the chair and closed his eyes for a
moment.
“I would love that!” I answered.
“I’m just gonna go get these costumes that I’m working on, and I’ll sew
them here on the couch. Give me a minute
to set up, OK?” I went to the dining
room, and grabbed a few things to take back with me. I set up at the couch and began a painstaking
launch into circular small talk with my dad.
I am not good at small talk, and I was struggling. I was busy using a hot glue gun to put
sequins on dresses for an upcoming show my kids were doing at the high
school. I let my dad ramble on, and I
contributed giggles and responsive comments.
I felt weary, and realized my mom did this every single day. I told myself to “buck up” because no matter
how draining this seemed to me in the moment, it was a privilege to spend the
day with my dad, and it was an honor to be able to help my mom. I genuinely believed this, and it made me
smile as I busily burned the tips of my fingers with hot glue, suppressing
expletives.
At
one moment, my dad asked me to sing to him.
I am a music therapist, and I know that music is really important, and I
know that every time I have ever pulled out the guitar or keyboard and began
singing to my dad, he has jumped in, singing with me. However, I really was feeling the stress of
finishing these costumes. The show was
going to open in a couple of days, so time was of the essence. My mom had put the radio on right before she
left, and Christmas songs rolled in one right after the other (as it was
mid-November). I began singing with the
radio, familiar songs to my dad, and he sang along. We laughed a bit. I was still busy with my costumes, paying
half attention to my dad’s interjections.
At one moment, though, he said something to me that caught my attention.
“I
want you to sing to me. I want you to
sing eighteen songs to me. I’ve always
just wanted that. I can’t believe you are
here with me right now. I wanted to see
you so much, and when I woke up – well, here you are! It’s like a dream come
true. I could just follow you around all
day, every day, and you could sing to me.”
He looked dreamily in my direction.
“Christmas
songs?” I asked, still not committed to
the conversation.
“No. No, not Christmas songs. Those other ones you used to do all the
time.” I thought about which songs he
might mean. Here was my chance to pull
him to me for a moment. Now it was not
Cliff making random statements to a kind stranger who was babysitting him. Now he was really talking to me, Laura, his
daughter. He was remembering my whole
life of music.
“My
love songs? The ones I would
write?” I waited for his response, to
see if he was really with me.
“Yes! Those… You know, I was always the one who
loved those. Your mother, she liked them
alright. But, I’m the one who really
loved them.” He smiled. I thought about that. I think he was right. My mom loved me, and therefore loved all my music because it was part of
me. But, my dad is the one who dreamed,
I think, about me making it big someday.
There were times when his support and energy were infectious, even. I laughed a little.
“I
think you’re right, dad. You love my
music differently than Mom does.”
“I
just want you to record about eighteen or twenty of them for me. Could you do that?” He smiled at me sweetly.
“I
will do that. How about I do that, and
make it your Christmas present?” I mentally searched my brain to see where and
how I could make this happen. I lived in
both Southwest Michigan, and Los Angeles, bouncing back and forth to be with my
husband and children. My stuff is
scattered across the whole country. This
would be a challenge…
“I
would love that. I would really love
that,” he said. Then he repeated, “I
just want to follow you around and listen to you all the time. All we would do is music.” I was still acting busy on my costumes, and
trying to chat with him.
“We
would get so hungry, Dad. If all we did
was music, when could we eat?” I thought
it was a silly and light response.
“Aw,
babes, music is better than a lot of food.” He was smiling at me. I stopped and looked at him.
“True,”
I agreed.
“You
ever heard about food for the soul?” He
paused, as it was a rhetorical question.
I nodded anyway. “That’s music,”
he said.
That
was the moment. That was the moment I
put my costumes aside, and sat up. I
felt that I needed to become a listener, and I needed to make my dad a
priority. I realized that I was wasting
precious time with him, busying myself with some cloth that would wait.
And
so began a two-and-a-half hour talk with my dad that felt like a dream-- a talk
that seemed like something of a riddle, or a poem. My dad’s ability to understand what is
happening to him strikes me as uncanny.
I have met a lot of people who have dementia. I have never talked with one who so
eloquently and intelligently could express to me what it feels like to have it,
though – until my dad. Yesterday, he
gave me a glimpse. He gave me a gift.
I
stopped my busy crafting, pulled out a notebook, and began to take notes, while
my dad’s words became ingredients to a word-salad of statements that made
sense, fully surrounded by paragraphs that didn’t. His themes included journeys and death and
peace, as well as this idea of finishing a big project. He talked about writing a book, and needing
help. At one point he began talking
about climbing – as if it were the side of a big mountain, he said. He talked about slipping and falling. I told him that it was scary for me to think
of him falling. I told him that it was
hard to think of him getting hurt.
He
looked up at me, and said, “It’s not me hurting that’s so bad. It’s you seeing me hurt.” I pondered that,
and wrote it in my notebook. He noticed
me writing and said, “I hope you’re getting this all down, ‘cuz I’m gonna need
some help getting it out there.”
“I’m
going to do my best, Dad,” I said. I
smiled, and made conscious efforts to not feel sad about the things he was
saying, or the way he was saying them to me.
I paid careful attention to his tones, his moments of frustration or
joy, hoping to help him express himself in ways that would relieve some of his
anxieties. I had read about this in my
hospice book, a book given to me for training while working with exactly my
dad’s population. The writers of the
book stressed that everything becomes important, and sometimes the things an
individual is trying to express can seem hidden in coded phrases. I recognized that my dad was excited and
talking deeply, in ways he hadn’t done often lately, and I realized that I
needed to stay in this moment – these moments – with him.
He
talked a lot about my mom. He talked
about how beautiful she was. Many times
he stopped and told me, “She’s a great girl.
She just… she loves me. She is
just so wonderful.” I agreed each time.
(My mom is really amazing. It was not
hard to agree with my dad).
“Sometimes
I run my hand from the curve of her neck, all the way down her back…” Tears
sprang to his eyes. He looked at me.
“I
ask myself, ‘Is this my wife? How is
this possible? She is just so
beautiful.’” I paused for a moment,
fighting my own tears. I thought of my
dad, the lover; my dad, the husband of my mom.
I knew that they had their own love story, and that, even with its
bumps, it was a beautiful one. As
quickly as my dad brought up the topic, he moved through it. It was like taking a journey with someone
through a tornado. This was not a
straight and chronological memory lane.
The best I can describe my dad’s thought-tornados would be to describe
the storm in the old movie-version of The
Wizard of Oz… swirling winds, juxtaposed objects. A cow.
This was what it was like to sit and have conversation with my dad.
“She
gets so stressed. I know it has to be
hard, all that she’s doing here. She has
such a beautiful smile, and I wish I could see it more often.” He looked a little wistful as he talked about
my mom. I could see that he understood
in that moment that my mom was under a lot of pressure to care for him. Here was that uncanny awareness, showing
itself.
“She
has always processed stress that way,” I said. “I think it’s hard for her to
relax sometimes.” I silently realized that I would be a ball of boa-constrictor-muscles
if I was living with the fear of losing my husband, watching him descend into
end days the way my father was spiraling downward into the darkness of
Alzheimer’s.
“It
is!” Dad agreed. He then looked at
me. “You are like her. You are so much like her.” I knew he meant that I was like her in the
loving and warm ways, as well as the jittery, busy ways. I smiled.
I knew this already. I think I
have always known this.
“Thank
you,” I responded. “I find that to be a
big compliment. When I was younger, I
used to not like it as much. That makes
me laugh.” I stopped. “When you are
young, you want your own way of doing things.
When you get older, you embrace the parts of you that are like your mom,
I guess.” I said the last part, realizing that it wasn’t my dad to whom I
spoke, but to myself.
“Yep. She’s a wonderful girl,” Dad repeated.
“You
know -- it was so odd,” he continued. “I
reached right on in here, and there was all this stuff. I was working hard on it, making things. You know how I do. I had it all over the table, the stuff, and
then there was this – this thing, on
the table. And it was marked with a
price tag. The tag said fifty-nine
cents. Can you believe that? Who on earth would do such a thing? And you know what it was?” He looked at me, as if I ought to know what
he meant.
“Was
it a model airplaine?” I asked. I
thought he was talking about the stuff he liked to make. I thought he was asking me about what the
object was. I did not realize he was
referring to the price tag until he spoke again.
“No. It was a reminder. It was saying, ‘Don’t you think too highly of
yourself!’ Man, was that humbling.” He laughed.
He was not sad as he told me this.
My dad, through all of his decline in memory and thought-processing, has
been able to maintain perfect vocal inflection.
It is so interesting to me to observe.
Many other folks I have met with Alzheimer’s have lost their animated
facial expression and variety of pitch in speech. My dad is still so interesting to listen to,
and to watch talk. He laughs and smiles
and moves his head and hands, talking about things like he always did. It’s quite amazing.
“That
is a great reminder!” I thought
instantly about how humbling this evil disease is. I knew this was to what he was referring;
and, yet, I did not agree with that awful fifty-nine-cent sticker. I did not wish to see this disease take a
man’s dignity the way it seemed bent on doing.
Dad’s lighthearted approach to acceptance was helpful for me. I hoped
that deep inside he was able to have this peace that he seemed to be
exemplifying.
“This
is special stuff. I don’t know what it
is about talking to you, but I’ve never told anyone this stuff before. I want to.
I mean, I just have this collection of special stuff. And right on in there, I reach right inside,
and there’s a clock. I look at the
clock, and I know time’s runnin’ out.” He thought for a beat. Then he
continued. “I haven’t got much time left.”
I
fought a lump in my throat. Individuals
who are dying have a special awareness, some people believe. I fought waves of fear, even as I knew my dad
was hungry to tell someone all these things.
He was trying to express something.
I strained to meet him where he was, to continue offering processing
statements to help him get to the heart of what he needed to say. I could sense
that, even with the richness of what he’d already stated -- all these nuggets
of love and profundity -- he had not yet said what he needed to say.
“Are
you scared?” I asked.
“To
die? No! I’m not scared about that.” I
watched him as his whole body was at ease.
I knew he was telling the truth.
“I’m ready. Oh, I’ve been ready
for a long time! I have peace about
this.”
Well,
I thought. Nothing like addressing the elephant in the
room. My dad was so transparent at
this time. It helped me to be, as
well. It helped me to talk with him in a
space that was drenched with authenticity.
He wasn’t afraid to talk about his own mortality, and so it would
behoove me to go there with him. I
realized that I would find comfort if I could know that he was at peace, as he
kept saying. I watched him search to
express something before he began speaking again. What is
it, Dad? What are you trying to say?
“Your
mom’s a great girl,” he repeated, as he’d said several times already in our
visit. “She’s just so lovely. Every day she is so kind and loving. She does everything around here. I wish I could…” (He never seemed to be able
to finish the statements of what he wished he could do, when talking about my
mom).
“Are
you afraid that mom is not gonna be OK, Dad?” I wondered if that was why he
seemed restless, and also why he kept talking about peace, following it up with
how wonderful my mom was.
He
sighed heavily. “She’s really strong,”
he stated.
“She
is strong,” I agreed. “She will be sad, and it will hurt. But, I do believe she will be OK, Dad.”
“I
just, I have peace…” I knew he had said
this before in our conversation, this talk of peace. What was it that he was trying to get
at?
“I
have peace,” he said again. “I just want her to have peace, too.” His eyes filled with tears. Mine did, too. “I just want my wife to be able to have
peace. I want her to be OK. I know I don’t have long – but, whether it’s
three months, or three years – I want her to have peace about it. I’ll know when it’s time.”
“Do
you want me to tell her this?” I asked cautiously.
“Yes! I mean, I reach right here, and I think about
all those things. You know what’s right
here?” Dad asked. I looked and saw his
hand on his heart.
“It’s
your heart, Dad,” I said. I thought it
was powerful that he was talking about my mom and peace, while also connecting
to his heart. This amazed me, this
outpouring of love. I was not prepared
for his response to me, though.
“No! This is where the clock is!” He laughed and
shook his head. “This is where that
timer is.”
I
felt myself suck in air through a tiny, invisible straw. I wanted to cry, and told myself that my
tears would not be helpful at this moment.
I did not wish to stop my dad from expressing himself.
“Some
understand, some don’t,” my dad continued.
“I just feel scared, I guess.”
“Are
you scared because you feel alone?” I
wasn’t sure where he was going with this new development in the conversation.
“Oh! No!
I’m not alone. I’m never alone,”
my dad said, and he pointed to the sky.
He smiled, comforted. “But it
sure would be nice if Karen, and Mike, and the other kids were all around
me. Mike’s my son, and he’s just so
great. I know he’s got faith. I worry
about the other kids.”
I
smiled. I knew that I was temporarily
not Laura, his daughter. He referred to
my mom as “Karen,” and talked of my brother as if he were introducing a new
person to our conversation. I never tried
to make him remember that I was his daughter, but I also never stopped calling
him “Dad,” or saying “Mom” in our interactions, even after he’d referred to her
as “Karen,” or “my wife.”
“I
believe all of your kids have faith, Dad.
Is that what you are worried about?”
I didn’t know how deep this part of the conversation was going to go,
and I also did not want to misrepresent my siblings, even if my dad would
forget this part of the conversation within a minute of saying it.
“Oh,
I know my son does. I just worry about
some of the others. I worry that they
play at it,” he said. He smiled at me.
“You know what I mean?”
“I
do. I know what you mean. But, I don’t think you need to worry about
that, Dad.”
Dad
continued to chatter away without direction.
And then he said to me, “I know I’m not making sense. I don’t think anybody understands me. How could they? And then I think, ‘This must
be what it feels like to be going mad.’”
He stared at me and said it again, “This must really be what it’s like
to be going mad.” He looked a little
disgusted.
“It
must be really frustrating,” I said. I
didn’t know what else to say. What was I
supposed to say? Yes. It seems like madness! I think not. In fact, so much of what he was saying made
perfect sense, as long as I was able to follow the poetry in his speech. As long as I was able to be a word detective
with him, I was gleaning incredible depth from his strange and beautiful
statements.
“Yes! It is very frustrating!” He seemed relieved that someone would
validate that with him and not try to tell him that it was fine. He was aware that it was not fine. He didn’t need me to pretend I wasn’t hearing
the circular speech.
“What
are you doing there?” he asked, pointing at my costumes. I’d been slowly alternating
working on my costumes and writing down my dad’s words throughout our visit.
“Oh,
I’m working on some costumes for the show the kids are doing at the high
school. They’re doing Guys and Dolls. You know – the musical
with Frank Sinatra? The one where the
girls sing, “I love you, a bushel and a peck, a bushel and a peck…” I started to sing the song. Dad joined in with me. We sang all the way through to the end. Then we giggled together.
“Oh
boy!” Dad exclaimed. “That was great!
You’d think you’ve got some McDermott genes in you, or something,” he said to
me.
“Or
something!” I said, in a silly way. I
said it in a silly way, to mask the pain of realizing that once again, my dad
had slipped from remembering that I was Laura McDermott, his daughter. “I got lots of McDermott-genes in me,” I
continued. “Can’t ya tell?” I pointed to my fuzzy red mop of hair on top
of my head. My crazy hair was an icon. In every decade of my life, you could find a
picture of me with my hair tumbling all around in a messy swirl of varying
degrees of strawberry, cinnamon, and blond.
It was the one constant about me.
My dad laughed heartily.
“Aw,
I’m so glad you’re here visiting with me.
I have missed you so much! I said
to myself, ‘Boy, I’d sure like to visit my sister!’ And, here you are,” he
said. “This is great.”
Aunt Diane. I know I look like her right now. I think that he thinks I’m Aunt Diane in this
moment.
The
phone rang, and he answered. It was a
friend of my mom’s, and I smiled as I heard my dad talk in ways that, I’m sure,
had to be confusing to the caller. I
hoped she was someone who already knew that he was not able to relay messages
to my mom with consistency. I heard him
say, “Well, my sister’s here. Maybe she
can –“ and then he looked at me and spoke.
“Wait, who are you?”
“Tell
her it’s Laura, your daughter.” I smiled
and kept right on gluing sequins to the costumes. Somehow, it really didn’t bother me to tell
my dad that.
“Oh! You’re my daughter! Here I thought I’d been visiting with my
sister this whole time!” he exclaimed jovially.
I knew that he only had thought this for the last five minutes, but that
was OK. He told the lady on the phone it
was his daughter, and then handed the phone to me, telling me she wanted to
talk to me. I took down a message for my
mom, and said goodbye to the sweet woman on the other end of the phone. I decided to keep the phone next to me, in
the event there would be future calls during my mom’s absence. Not every caller
would be as understanding or as informed about my dad’s condition, I figured.
After
the phone, my dad asked where my mom was again.
I told him she was at the doctor’s but would be home soon. He asked about the costumes again, and we
sang “Bushel and a Peck,” again. He
asked about my husband – where he was.
He was disappointed when I told him that my husband was back at work in
Los Angeles. Dad said he really liked “that
guy,” and that he wanted to just have him come and visit for a long time so he
could really get to know him. I agreed
that it sounded lovely.
Then
my dad started talking with a sense of urgency again. He talked about objects. He continued to reference projects and
climbing and traveling. He said, “I had
ahold of something, and it was one of those…”
He was lost. He couldn’t think of
the word. He looked at me. “You know!
One of those things that’s really important to people.” He waited for me to have the word. I scanned my brain for what he might
mean.
“An
heirloom?” I finally asked. I really hoped that was what he meant, because
I was terrible at playing word-guessing games.
“Yes! An heirloom!
That’s it!” he exclaimed. “It was
nothing much. Just a note. I reached right in my pocket and pulled it
out. It was a note.”
“What
was in the note?” I asked.
“It
was all this stuff.” He swirled his hand
around. Dad seemed to mean everything he
had been sharing with me, all the words.
“What
did you do with the note, Dad?” I asked him.
“Well,
I handed it to you!” He said matter-of-factly.
This
impacted me deeply. I felt a sense of
responsibility. He had mentioned several
different ways during our visit that he wanted me to write down what he was
saying, that he wanted me to know he had never shared this with anyone else,
and that he needed me to be diligent about sharing the information he was
giving me.
“Do
you want me to share the note?” I
asked. I mean, I think I asked it. The whole conversation was surreal. I felt as though I was caught up in a dream
sequence with my dad, so some of my exact responses are fuzzy to me. In my mind’s eye, my dad indicated that he
wanted me to share the note. Whether he
said it or not, he had earlier told me to write everything down because he
needed my help to “get it out there.”
“I
have all this stuff in there – in the AWOL bag.
I reached in my AWOL bag, and would you believe everything fell out! It was upside down and everything fell out,
but the last thing was all set. It was
still in there.” He started talking this
way, and I felt it was connected to the other conversation about the note, but
a little confusing to me. I felt very
clearly that he was talking about a journey again, about getting the heck out
of dodge – what with the AWOL bag and all.
He was talking about dying again.
“What
was the last thing, Dad? What’s left in the bag?” I wondered what he would say.
“Well,
it was me!” he laughed. He shook his
head like I should have known the answer already.
I
smiled through my tears. Yes, you are
still here. You are still in the bag,
you strange and beautiful man, you.
“This
is my last meal,” he announced just before my mom came home. “But, I don’t know how long it will go on.”
Nope. We don’t know how long.
I
cherish this talk with my dad. Strange Beauty, it is.
No comments:
Post a Comment