Monday, September 10, 2018

Sacrifice: Does one population own it over another?

Dear Friends, Family, and Strangers alike,

We can't judge someone for going through something we never have.  And, one of my best role models during my internship for becoming a board certified music therapist once helped me to understand that even if the details were the same, our individual experiences are not.

I, as a white woman growing up in a safe home with food on the table and support for education, will never know the struggle many of my friends and neighbors had while growing up. I don't know how it feels to lose my loved one to gang-related violence. I don't know what it feels like to fear for my life because of the color of my skin. I don't know what it's like to lose my husband. I don't know what it's like to lose my son.  I don't know what it's like to send my police-officer-husband into harm's way every day.

I've been degraded and disrespected by police officers, though, and raped by men who had been in our United States military. I certainly don't believe everyone choosing these life-callings are good, upstanding people, nor do I assume all police officers and military personnel are disrespectful, raping pricks. I am able to understand that we have good, and we have bad.

Here's the thing: life is intrinsically valuable. Your life, my life, a soldier's life, a police officer's life, a rapper's life, a football player's life, a McDonald's worker's life, a teacher's life, a student's life, a lawyer's life, a doctor's life, an actuary's life, a factory worker's life... I could go on. We're all valuable, and losing one of us isn't more devastating, tragic, and painful than losing another one of us.  No one is entitled to more "important" grief based on the status of the deceased.

My dad had a contract with the Detroit Tigers to be a pitcher in the early 50's when pitchers also had to swing the bat and run the bases.  He had a moment where, as we've often told the story, he lost everything. He had a horrific car accident and it played a big role in destroying his leg, thus destroying his American dream of being a professional baseball player. Years of painful processing of this ensued. I do believe much of my dad's depression and sometimes anger stemmed from being a real human who went through something life- changing and traumatic like this.

One could say he lost everything he'd previously dreamed of achieving.

He went on to marry, have children, become a preacher. His heart was still shaped like a baseball. We learned to pitch a ball before we walked, practically. So, he had a beautiful and fulfilling life after he lost his dream. I do believe this. But that does not somehow erase his pain of having lost everything.

This backstory is meant to pave the way for a conversation to happen.

Colin Kaepernick is not an evil, disrespectful man.  In fact, his public faith as a strong Christian seems like it would strike a chord with more people. I never hear people talk about his faith. I only hear so-called Christians whine about the fact that he didn't sacrifice anything, and then people throw in their stories of what real sacrifice looks like (from fallen soldiers and police officers to Jesus, himself, on the cross). Look, no one that I know is saying that Jesus and the soldiers and police have not sacrificed. I just think it's odd that people need to measure sacrifice. Like, if we're actually going to "use" Jesus, we really need to understand that NO ONE else can possibly measure up, so stop putting police officers and soldiers on the Jesus-level.

It's frustrating to me to see so many people misunderstand Colin, who chose his visible status as a risky opportunity to make a statement about change that needs to happen. He DID get us talking. I'm continuously floored by the ugliness that comes out of some folks regarding this.

"Colin is wrong. He didn't sacrifice anything. My husband/ brother/son/uncle/ dad/ friend made the REAL sacrifice, and so did Jesus."

Hmm. Colin lost his dream. Just like my dad.  He's living every day with results of standing up for something that, in turn,  cost him his career. He's talked about by many as if he isn't a worthy human. Please understand, as you post your memes about what real sacrifice looks like, that there are parents, spouses, siblings and friends in our towns whose sacrifice was also ultimate, when their loved one was gunned down, possibly by a police officer who, for any number of reasons, made a costly judgment and error. When an African-American mom buries her son because a police officer thought the kid had a gun but it was a cell phone, it's not somehow less tragic or less of a sacrifice than when an officer is killed.

Just because you or I do not experience the same kind of racial profiling and prejudice that our neighbors of color experience does not mean that it doesn't exist/ isn't a problem/ is an issue that is in the past. It happens. I could link dozens of articles demonstrating that it happens. One could, I know, dogmatically cough up an article by a black writer who states, based on his personal experience, that it isn't that bad (prejudice). So many people are willing to reference this one person as the only black person whose experience matters, blindly ignoring or knowingly refuting the hundreds of other accounts of real humans to which it has happened.  Dogmatism is when one looks for ways to prove herself right. Well, with that mindset, one can expect 100% success. We can always find articles and situations to prove ourselves right.

The real trick is to try and prove oneself wrong.

This isn't about our personal experience as much as it is about the human condition.  "I'VE never experienced this, so it must not actually happen."

Well, I have experienced some extreme trauma by people being heralded in memes as our true heroes who've "sacrificed it all," or who've so patriotically been willing to sacrifice it all. Yet, I still recognize that my personal experience is just that. Personal.

I can't say all police officers and military are great, because I personally know this to not be true.  Do I respect our men and women who selflessly answer the call to do these difficult and dangerous professions? Absolutely.

But, [you] cannot blindly say that they're all upstanding and good, either. They aren't, and my experience actually proves that.

If we've not been the recipient of racial profiling, we simply cannot argue that it doesn't happen. And we cannot pretend that our experiences exemplify the entirety of the subject in question.  We represent, actually, a personal and limited viewpoint.

I grew up Baptist (you know-- like the church with which Colin Kaepernick identifies himself...) and we did communion once a month. I knew of somebody who was really struggling with a personal issue in his life, and it prevented him from feeling peace in his spiritual relationship. You know what he did? He refrained from participating in communion. Did you know that's actually written about in the Bible?

So, why can someone sit out communion (with blessing) while trying to address an issue, but he cannot sit out the National Anthem while attempting to address an issue? Why? (Is it more important to be patriotic than to be in communion with God? Check yourself).

We have some issues that need addressing regarding race. How do we best recommend getting that conversation started?  If you, reading this, are angry that anyone would suggest that we need to reform our concept of our great melting pot here in America,  please consider asking yourself if you are basing your "understanding" of life experiences on your own experiences. Most of us do this! If you are, please consider opening your heart and mind, and at least trying to understand through empathy what it might be like, how your experiences and interactions with some authority figures might be different, if you were a different person with a different color skin, coming from a different part of town.

I've never bought anything Nike before. But, I'm thinking about it.  I'm impressed that they have openly decided to acknowledge this conversation that so many are willing to put to bed without resolution.

Sincerely,

Laura Lee